Showing posts with label reviews.. Show all posts
Showing posts with label reviews.. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 23, 2012

An Interesting Concept for Reviews in General

I've always maintained one single account for the web sites where I review or rate...anything. On Amazon I have one single account, under my own name, Ryan Field, that I'm sure could be traced if it had to be. On Goodreads, it's the same scenario. Just one GR account, with my real name and identity, not a fake. I do sometimes comment on threads as anon in blog discussions, or with a fake name. But not often, and only when I don't think it's important for my identity to be revealed. Sometimes there are reasons to do these things. For example, (I know you're waiting for a reason) I follow and love one blogger who writes middle grade fiction. I don't think it's appropriate for me, due to the subject matter of what I write, to comment on his middle grade thread. I love his work, and yet he doesn't even know who I am.

To make this point even clearer, right now I'm using a pen name for a book that's been difficult to write. The publisher asked me to use the pen name; it wasn't my choice. I'm not fond of doing this, I don't like doing this, and I've basically done nothing to promote that book. I've tried to get into it. I've tried to promote the book and the pen name. But it's not working. At this point in my career, I don't think it's worth risking my own real identity for the sake of a pen name that means nothing to me. And once the next book is finished, that's the last book the series will ever see with me attached to it. And if this doesn't prove how strongly I feel about my identity, nothing ever will.

To reiterate: I only have one account on each review site with my own name. If necessary, these accounts could be traced back to me. This way I know what I wrote, when I wrote it, and I can be held accountable for everything I've put into writing. I do this for various personal reasons and I feel very strongly about these reasons. I learned years ago I have nothing to hide, and if I'm going to put something in writing I don't mind being held accountable for it. I'm also well past the days of meltdown when it comes to getting bad reviews, so THAT can be scratched off the list. My meltdown days ended about four years ago. I don't really care if my name comes up in comment threads either. If you don't think so, ask me and watch me smile.

One account and identity is what most people do, I believe. I know this is what my mom does with her Amazon account, and it's what my good friends do. The one thing I've always had a problem with is leaving bad reviews. I prefer to leave good reviews for books I like instead of focusing on bad reviews with books I didn't like. And I don't like to attack other authors, just like doctors don't like to attack other doctors and teachers don't like to attack other teachers. For me it's more about solidarity and collaboration. And just because I don't like something doesn't mean it's not good. So I will admit that's my review flaw. But that's not going to change. Some things are just too subjective to be objective.

I actually stopped all google alerts in April of 2009 and rarely ever read my own reviews because I don't think it's a place where I should go. When people review my books they should have the ability to go there without me looking over their shoulders or getting involved in their discussions about my books. I don't belong there. In fact, I don't even like it when I see publishers leave ratings and reviews for books. I respect all opinions, good or bad. I've also learned...and posted about here before...that not all bad reviews hurt authors and books. Sometimes they help. I've also posted many times before that I've found some of the books I've loved the most from reading bad reviews. That's how I found "Fifty Shades of Grey," through a bad review, long before it went mainstream.

I think it's important (for me) to stand behind my name and my identity and to enforce how strongly I feel about using my own name and identity in case anything questionable ever does crop up. Others may disagree with me and that's fine.

But there is one thing I'd love to see added to review sites with everyone's profile, including mine. I understand that some people have to use pen names for various reasons and I don't see anything wrong with that. But I'd like to know just how many pen names and accounts they actually have from the same IP address. Now that would be interesting, if not entertaining. Because if the number of accounts started to appear on everyone's profile and it turned out that some had multiple identities, I'm not sure what I would think. I might not think twice if I saw someone had two or three fake names and identities. That's plausible, I guess. But what about if they had five, six, seven, or more fake names. Like I said, I understand the need for pen names. But I'm not so sure I understand the need for multiple identities, with an extended number.

Unfortunately, this will never happen...at least not in my lifetime. But it is very entertaining to think about it. I'm also sure that some who read this post will still question who I am and if this really is my real name and identity. It seems no matter how hard I try to get the point across there are always some who are so jaded by Internet deception they won't believe me. That's unfortunate. Because I might just show up, in the flesh, in person, someplace high profile when I'm least expected. Maybe I can get my buddy Ryan to come with me because he's experienced similar things and he's not even an author. RWA might be a great place to start.

Tuesday, May 15, 2012

Do You Ever Read a Book You KNOW You Won't Like?

The title of this post sounds ridiculous at a glance. Seriously, who on earth would buy and read a book they know they aren't going to like? For that matter, who on earth would even read a free book or a discounted book they know they aren't going to like?

And we all know, for the most part, whether we're going to like a book or not. Of course there are cases where it's not always easy to tell and we wind up disappointed in something we thought would be better. It's happened to me. But usually the cover, the blurb, and the excerpt help us decide on whether or not a book is for us. If that fails, the reader reviews usually help make the final decision.

For example, I know I would never read a romance novel with a cover that had a woman with a flowing gown, a trite tag line that might do well in David Letterman's top ten list, and exaggerated font with curls at the end of each word (I wouldn't even have one visible in my home for guests to see). Even if I thought I might like a romance novel with a woman in a flowing gown, I would read the blurb and the excerpt just to be sure. Nine times out of ten the excerpt makes the decision for me. In books like this I usually see too many adverbs and said bookisms. And when I see more than one said bookism or adverb on the first page, that's the dealbreaker for me.

Now that's just my own personal taste. I prefer fiction that's tightly written, and practices word economy. I think this can be done in romance, and it can be done well. I've seen it done well. But the point of this post is that I wouldn't read the book with the woman in the gown, not even for free. I'm sure many would disagree. But it's just my own personal, subjective taste.

And yet I've seen something interesting happening in a few places on the Internet. I just don't get it. A book reviewer on a review site will read the first book in a series and hate it. They not only hate it, they roast the book, the author, and the publisher. And, it's usually done in that forced quasi snark way (I'm a bitch, oh yeah, that's me, funny-funny, slap-your-knee, haha, deal with it), with a mom and pop tone, that's almost funny but in this case would never make it to David Letterman's top ten list.

Of course there's nothing wrong with giving a bad review. I truly, deeply believe everyone has the right to review and express opinions about a book...or anything on the Internet, without question. I've left my own bad reviews that range from opinions about books to clothing I've purchased. But when the same book reviewer reads the second book, and then the third book in a series where she already HATED the first book, I have to wonder what the mind-set behind this is. What is motivating her to read something she clearly knows she will hate?

In other words, if you hated the first book in the series so much, the odds state you're not going to fall in love with the second book. The odds are the people who read the first review about the first book will not take a chance on buying the second book in the series either. The job has been done, so to speak. I would simply move on to a book that I KNOW I'm going to love...or at least a book I think I might like based on the information given to me. Life's too short to waste time doing things I KNOW I'm not going to like.

Maybe I'm missing something here. Maybe people who do things like this are such good, honest, decent, ethical people they want to give the second and third book in the series another chance. Maybe they are hoping they will love it so much they will be able to write a wonderful, positive review without the fake mom and pop snark and forced comedy that is beginning to get really tired on the Internet. Or maybe they just do it because all the world does love a clown...even a BAD clown. It's been said, and I paraphrase this from the old song, "Be a Clown," that if you can quack like a fucking duck the checks will keep coming.

Thursday, March 22, 2012

Will "Fifty Shades of Grey" Change the Internet in Some Ways?


I've already explained how I discovered "Fifty Shades of Grey," here in this post. I've discovered many books I love by doing this...reading a bad review on what's considered a professional online review site and checking the book out for myself. With this particular web site where books are reviewed, nine times out of ten I wind up loving the book and wondering why the reviewer hated it. If it happened once I'd think it was me. But when it happens dozens and dozens of times I start to think that maybe the review site I'm checking out is catering to a smaller more elite crowd of readers. Or, maybe I DO have horseshit taste (smile).

I think it's important to state first that I do respect ALL reviewers, and I believe everyone has the right to an opinion, especially when it comes to books. I've also found some of the most wonderful books I've ever read by going to review sites and reading the good reviews. The theme of this post is not to bash ANY reviewers or even question them. It's to examine the disconnect I've been seeing lately between what's discussed online and what's discussed in the mainstream. For example, when "Bridges of Madison County," was released it was a huge mainstream success, and yet there are still people bashing the book online to this day. The same thing happened with "Twilight." We all know how some so-called online "experts" feel about Amanda Hocking. And now I'm seeing the same with with "Fifty Shades of Grey."

I read FSoG and loved it (thanks to that scathing review on that one particular web site where books are reviewed). I also read BoMC and "Twilight" and loved them, too. I haven't read Amanda Hocking yet, but the odds are I'll like her work at the very least. I don't think anyone would have guessed that FSoG would every become as big a book as it is right now. When I bought it I would never have guessed this. But now I read something about it everywhere I go. And here's the interesting thing. If you go to any mall in any suburban town in the USA and you ask people at random if they've ever heard of the review site where I read the review that slammed FSoG before it went mainstream, I'd bet money no one in the mall would know who you were talking about. But go to the same mall and ask them if they've heard of FSoG. I'll bet at least half would know the book you are talking about. This proves one thing: the Internet has come a long way, but still has a long way to go. Most people, in the real world, don't know half of what's going on in online publishing communities. And they don't care either.

The most interesting thing is that FSoG started out as an online book and did the impossible by crossing into the mainstream. I've read allegations about it being fanfic and I don't think that's even significant at this point. FSoG has sparked interest and people are reading it and liking it. If you don't believe me, check out Amazon reviews where 580 people have reviewed and rated the first book and it has a four star average. If a fanfic author managed to get a big book and cross into the mainstream, I couldn't be more thrilled for her. That's all I care about. And though I can't say the book's worst online critics have been proven wrong because reviewing books is subjective (no one can be wrong when they review a book and that's important to state), I can say that the book's most serious critics have proven that their personal taste in books can now be questioned in a very big way. At the very least their taste can be questioned with regard to what the mainstream public wants to read.

As more people in the mainstream discover more about the Interwebs, through iPads and tablets and devices that connect them to online information, I can't help but wonder whether or not the credibility of web sites like the one where I read the scathing review of FSoG will diminish in time. In the past they've attracted an elite set of readers that tend to think the same way they do (or they are terrified to disagree with them). In their small online world they've been very popular. But will the mainstream find web sites like this too elite, and will the content they've been putting out in the last decade begin to look less trustworthy because their taste is so off with regard to the mainstream. I don't mean to say they aren't telling the truth. I believe they are passionate and they believe in what they are doing. I'm only wondering about whether or not their own personal truth is something the mainstream public will take seriously...or even care about. And will they remain relevant? Evidently, FSoG is a good example of how strongly the mainstream disagrees with what's considered credible online.