This is a little rant about something I read on a book review blog the other day. The reviewer in question slammed a story because one of the characters didn't know what GPS was. It was suggested in this review that anyone under the age of 70 should know what GPS is, and therefore the author didn't know what she was doing.
Well.
I find this interesting. I'm forty; I still run every morning, still have a thirty-two inch waist, and have been told I could pass for someone in his thirties...well under the age of 70. I own two cars and both have GPS. I have an iPhone with apps for GPS. And I honestly could not tell you, in detail, what the hell GPS is about or how to use it.
Why?
Because I don't care. I don't need GPS at this point in my life, and frankly I'm not even sure I ever will. I know it's some kind of navigational tool. I would imagine it comes in handy for people who travel for work, especially in sales. I'm not knocking GPS. But I'm a writer. I work at home. I know how to drive into to New York and find the Lincoln Tunnel without any problems at all. I rarely take the Holland, but could find it just as easily if I had to. I know how to get to any place between Maine and S. Beach Miami without any problems at all. I know how to get to the airport and the train station. If I need specific directions, which is rare, I stop and ask for them. Or, print out directions from google.
I'm sure there will come a day when I do need GPS. I like knowing that it is there just in case I ever do need it. I've even been telling myself that I have to sit down and learn how to use it...just in case that day comes when I need it. But at this point, GPS isn't something I need.
Now, this is interesting. My parents are retired therapists. They have GPS in both their cars, plus on their iPhones. They are both over 70 and they both use their GPS all the time. In fact, they don't go anywhere without turning it on. They know so much about GPS it could put you to sleep.
My point is that I don't see how a character in a book not knowing what GPS is should be relevant to a book review. As an author, there are things the reader should take for granted and not question. If an author thinks a character shouldn't know what GPS is, I don't think it should be questioned. I just finished a mystery romance where a character didn't know how to operate his GPS. I explained why he doesn't know how to operate it. But I don't think it's fair to assume that just because most people care about GPS the rest of the world should care.
And when I see reviews like this, those that pick out snitty little things like GPS, I can't help but wonder what kind of person the reviewer is. What would make a person think this way? To assume we all know about GPS, and then condemn an author for not thinking this way. But more than that, if I had been reviewing that particular book, I would have been more concerned about the author's poor use of dialogue tags...there were adverbs in every example in the review. I would have been more concerned about the author's use of said bookisms...he grumbled, mumbled, and stumbled, three lines in a row, no joke. But the last thing I would have cared about was that the character didn't know what GPS is.
An objective look at LGBT issues, fiction, book publishing, pop culture, and romance novels that may or may not be erotic romance, by a real gay author using his real name. Over 2 million posts since 2008.
Showing posts with label WTF?. Show all posts
Showing posts with label WTF?. Show all posts
Thursday, January 5, 2012
Saturday, November 12, 2011
Penn State: You Get One Childhood in this Life; Just One
You only get one childhood in this life. Just one. And when someone comes along and crushes it, you don't get a chance to do it over again.
Where I live, an hour and a half from New York and an hour from Philadelphia, we don't usually hear much about Penn State. I think it's something like five hours away, which in a state the size of PA is like Iowa to people who live around here. I know more about New Jersey than I do about PA. Hell, I know more about LA than I know about Penn State.
But the Philadelphia news channels have been focusing on what's been going on at Penn State, with regard to alleged child abuse and the alleged cover ups that occurred. And it's been both saddening and shocking to see how students at Penn State have reacted.
One of those people who allegedly covered the child abuse scandal up was Joe Paterno...AKA, "JoePa." Good old "JoePa" allegedly knew about the child abuse and never contacted the proper authorities.
And the faithful students at Penn State didn't like the fact that their storied, flawless "JoePa" was allegedly involved in the cover up, so they went berserk and rioted when they found out good old "JoePa" had been asked to resign by the board.
I think this rioting is what might also be called a young adult temper tantrum, where college age people jump up and down, stomp on the ground, and kick and scream, when things don't go their way. This time, mom and dad weren't around to give them a "time out."
These students obviously had very little concern for the helpless victims of this alleged child abuse on the night they rioted. If they had, they would have waited until all the facts were presented before they formed opinions about good old "JoePa." And I honestly find it difficult to believe that anyone in their right mind would riot until all the facts have been presented, especially when the allegations are so serious and children are involved. There's something seriously wrong going on over there. And it makes me wonder what kind of Kool Aide they are serving in the Student Union.
You only get one childhood in this life. Just one.
Where I live, an hour and a half from New York and an hour from Philadelphia, we don't usually hear much about Penn State. I think it's something like five hours away, which in a state the size of PA is like Iowa to people who live around here. I know more about New Jersey than I do about PA. Hell, I know more about LA than I know about Penn State.
But the Philadelphia news channels have been focusing on what's been going on at Penn State, with regard to alleged child abuse and the alleged cover ups that occurred. And it's been both saddening and shocking to see how students at Penn State have reacted.
One of those people who allegedly covered the child abuse scandal up was Joe Paterno...AKA, "JoePa." Good old "JoePa" allegedly knew about the child abuse and never contacted the proper authorities.
And the faithful students at Penn State didn't like the fact that their storied, flawless "JoePa" was allegedly involved in the cover up, so they went berserk and rioted when they found out good old "JoePa" had been asked to resign by the board.
I think this rioting is what might also be called a young adult temper tantrum, where college age people jump up and down, stomp on the ground, and kick and scream, when things don't go their way. This time, mom and dad weren't around to give them a "time out."
These students obviously had very little concern for the helpless victims of this alleged child abuse on the night they rioted. If they had, they would have waited until all the facts were presented before they formed opinions about good old "JoePa." And I honestly find it difficult to believe that anyone in their right mind would riot until all the facts have been presented, especially when the allegations are so serious and children are involved. There's something seriously wrong going on over there. And it makes me wonder what kind of Kool Aide they are serving in the Student Union.
You only get one childhood in this life. Just one.
Labels:
child abuse,
Joe paterno,
joepat,
Penn State riots,
this is unreal,
WTF?
Friday, November 11, 2011
If You're a Writer, Read This With Caution...
If you are a writer and you're struggling to get published, read this post with caution.
I suppose there are two ways to look at it. In the blog post where I read it first the blooger seemed to think it was something writers should read for inspiration.
Frankly, I don't buy into that. I think it's just more babble to confuse writers. I prefer my inspiration to come from success, not from failure and rejection.
But that's just a matter of opinion. And there are obviously people who would disagree with me.
I suppose there are two ways to look at it. In the blog post where I read it first the blooger seemed to think it was something writers should read for inspiration.
Frankly, I don't buy into that. I think it's just more babble to confuse writers. I prefer my inspiration to come from success, not from failure and rejection.
But that's just a matter of opinion. And there are obviously people who would disagree with me.
Friday, September 23, 2011
Facebook...WTF?
I've been on facebook since it first began. I think that's like six or seven years now. I heard about this thing called facebook from a friend in CA, and figured I'd try it out.
I thought it was simple. I liked it. I started connecting with old friends and started making knew ones. I was always careful to manage the privacy settings. And I'm not much of a photographer so I rarely posted anything other than book covers.
But this new change in facebook is astounding. I'm getting e-mail notifications from status updates I never commented on or clicked "like." And I'm not getting notifications from those on which I did comment and click "like."
I'm not getting notifications about private messages, and I depend on these notifications because I connect with a lot of readers through private messages. I actually always preferred this to e-mails. For some reason it's easier.
So until I figure out what's going on over at facebook, don't take it personally if it takes me a little longer to get back with private messages. I'm now just checking the messages twice daily, where I used to just see the e-mail, click on the thread, and answer right away.
I'm also over at google+ now, too. But, frankly, it's just as complicated as facebook and I don't really have the time to sit and figure it out. I don't even know how to connect with people over there yet. I did figure out a way to "drag" names and add them to friend circles. But that's about it.
I thought it was simple. I liked it. I started connecting with old friends and started making knew ones. I was always careful to manage the privacy settings. And I'm not much of a photographer so I rarely posted anything other than book covers.
But this new change in facebook is astounding. I'm getting e-mail notifications from status updates I never commented on or clicked "like." And I'm not getting notifications from those on which I did comment and click "like."
I'm not getting notifications about private messages, and I depend on these notifications because I connect with a lot of readers through private messages. I actually always preferred this to e-mails. For some reason it's easier.
So until I figure out what's going on over at facebook, don't take it personally if it takes me a little longer to get back with private messages. I'm now just checking the messages twice daily, where I used to just see the e-mail, click on the thread, and answer right away.
I'm also over at google+ now, too. But, frankly, it's just as complicated as facebook and I don't really have the time to sit and figure it out. I don't even know how to connect with people over there yet. I did figure out a way to "drag" names and add them to friend circles. But that's about it.
Friday, July 1, 2011
Why Would Anyone Pirate an E-book That's Already Free?
I guess this post falls under my WTF category. I honestly don't get why anyone would pirate an e-book that's already free as much as I don't get DNF reviews or buying used books on Ebay for twice the cost of used books on amazon.
The other day I was in an author's group that was discussing pirating and how much it's hurting them. And one of the author's mentioned she has a free e-book out right now that's also being pirated. I did some checking around, and then found out from three other authors they've also had free e-books pirated.
Someone please tell me how this makes sense. Whenever I'm confronted by a book pirate they sound like relatively intelligent people. Morally and ethically flawed; no respect for the law; extremely crafty and shifty; but certainly not stupid. In some cases, they may even be smarter because they've figured out a way to rise above the law an not pay the penalties other people who break the law pay.
So what's the gain by pirating an e-book that's already out there for freaking free? Is it the thrill? Does it create that much of a high? You certainly can't use the excuse that those mean old publishers are pricing the book too high, and you can't blame it on authors who write bad books that disappoint you. You're already getting it for free...not tax or shipping...FREAKING FREE. Though I doubt anyone will respond, I'd love to hear something from an anonymous pirate, because this one has me stumped.
The other day I was in an author's group that was discussing pirating and how much it's hurting them. And one of the author's mentioned she has a free e-book out right now that's also being pirated. I did some checking around, and then found out from three other authors they've also had free e-books pirated.
Someone please tell me how this makes sense. Whenever I'm confronted by a book pirate they sound like relatively intelligent people. Morally and ethically flawed; no respect for the law; extremely crafty and shifty; but certainly not stupid. In some cases, they may even be smarter because they've figured out a way to rise above the law an not pay the penalties other people who break the law pay.
So what's the gain by pirating an e-book that's already out there for freaking free? Is it the thrill? Does it create that much of a high? You certainly can't use the excuse that those mean old publishers are pricing the book too high, and you can't blame it on authors who write bad books that disappoint you. You're already getting it for free...not tax or shipping...FREAKING FREE. Though I doubt anyone will respond, I'd love to hear something from an anonymous pirate, because this one has me stumped.
Tuesday, June 21, 2011
Solicit Reviews Through Your Blog? Another WTF Post...
I saw something interesting this morning and I'm wondering how other authors...and readers and reviewers...feel about this. You see, there's this new author out there soliciting reviews for his new release on his own blog. But more than that, he's doing this as a contest, and the person who writes the best review gets a signed copy of the book and a monetary bonus. He claims he's selecting the winner at random...but somehow I doubt "This S*^t Sux," is going to win first prize.
Now, correct me if I'm wrong here, but aren't book reviews designed to help readers make purchases? This is why all reviews aren't wonderful. When I shop around for books, I'm looking for the good reviews and the bad reviews. And if an author starts having review contests, where the best reviewer wins a prize, it stands to reasons that I'm going to question the validity of all the reviews he solicited in this contest.
I'm tempted to add links here. I really am. But I'm not going to do that because it might spark a flame war. And I'm not certain the author knows whether or not he's making a mistake. This one should know better, but I'm still not sure. And while it's questionable in an ethical and moral sense, I guess it's legal to solicit good book reviews and hold contests for good book reviews.
And what about book reviewers? If I were an online book reviewer and I saw an author do something like this, I'd be f**king livid. Like them or not, most of the book reviewers I read seem to take pride in their blogs and they don't screw around. I also followed an amazon comment thread for a long time and learned that most amazon reviewers take pride in what they do.
Feel free to disagree with me, but soliciting good book reviews by having a contest on your blog is downright tacky. And I can only promise my readers one thing. I'd never do this. I'll take the good with the bad, from professional reviewers and reader reviews, and hope I learn something from all the reviews.
Who knows? Maybe I'm wrong. Maybe a bad review will win the contest and it will be randomly selected. But I still have to wonder about any author who is willing to solicit reviews, through a contest, on his blog. Forget about authors, I don't even want to think about what would happen if a romance publisher started soliciting reviews and offering prizes through contests. The blogsphere would explode.
Update to this post: Evidently, the author I mentioned above has changed the rules. No more monetary prize in the contest. But I still can't help wondering about the basic concept.
Now, correct me if I'm wrong here, but aren't book reviews designed to help readers make purchases? This is why all reviews aren't wonderful. When I shop around for books, I'm looking for the good reviews and the bad reviews. And if an author starts having review contests, where the best reviewer wins a prize, it stands to reasons that I'm going to question the validity of all the reviews he solicited in this contest.
I'm tempted to add links here. I really am. But I'm not going to do that because it might spark a flame war. And I'm not certain the author knows whether or not he's making a mistake. This one should know better, but I'm still not sure. And while it's questionable in an ethical and moral sense, I guess it's legal to solicit good book reviews and hold contests for good book reviews.
And what about book reviewers? If I were an online book reviewer and I saw an author do something like this, I'd be f**king livid. Like them or not, most of the book reviewers I read seem to take pride in their blogs and they don't screw around. I also followed an amazon comment thread for a long time and learned that most amazon reviewers take pride in what they do.
Feel free to disagree with me, but soliciting good book reviews by having a contest on your blog is downright tacky. And I can only promise my readers one thing. I'd never do this. I'll take the good with the bad, from professional reviewers and reader reviews, and hope I learn something from all the reviews.
Who knows? Maybe I'm wrong. Maybe a bad review will win the contest and it will be randomly selected. But I still have to wonder about any author who is willing to solicit reviews, through a contest, on his blog. Forget about authors, I don't even want to think about what would happen if a romance publisher started soliciting reviews and offering prizes through contests. The blogsphere would explode.
Update to this post: Evidently, the author I mentioned above has changed the rules. No more monetary prize in the contest. But I still can't help wondering about the basic concept.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)