Thursday, May 5, 2011

The Interesting Thing About Gay Men...


In one sentence: The interesting thing about gay men is they are men.

I know this sounds a little too obvious to most people who don't know much about gay men. And when I say "don't know much," I'm talking about people who aren't gay and get their information from TV shows, Hollywood films, and some lgbt fiction. Notice I said "some" gay lgbt fiction. I'm not writing this post to single out anyone in particular. But I have seen a few lgbt books...one written by a national bestselling author...where a gay character was treated more like a woman than a man. The dialogue made me groan out out and I felt like tossing the book out the window. And, to be fair, it was a damn good book!

It's just that the author was faking it. She obviously has one or two gay friends in her life and she drew her information from them without going any deeper. Part of this is the fault of the silent, closeted sector of the lgbt community. For as long as I can remember, it's always been the loudest voices in the lgbt community who propagate the most stereotypes. Don't get me wrong. I love these people, all stereotypes aside. I love their courage and I love how they speak up for all of us. And, though I get a lot of flack for this, I personally don't mind stereotypes when used in appropriate circumstances. I think we've all become a little too PC...to the point where everyone is afraid to speak.

But the reason the vast majority of gay men aren't heard often is because they are men. Men don't think like women, they don't react like women, and they don't navigate the world like women. With men, it's black and white, with very few gray areas. Men react differently to sex as well. They don't seem to need as much emotion, and sex is more of a physical need than an emotional need. I'm not talking about "studies" now. I'm speaking from my own personal experience as a gay man and from my experiences with gay men. There's a reason psychologists have written bestselling books about the differences between men and women. And gay men, though I hate to burst anyone's bubble, think like men.

One of the least explored relationships, I think, are the friendships between gay men and straight men. I see TV shows, films, and books all the time where the gay guy always has a best girlfriend, the consummate fag hag. And yes, there are gay men like this. But most aren't. At least most of the gay men I know aren't. And, unfortunately, the reason why this is usually so hard to see is because half the gay men who are friends with straight men aren't open about being gay. In other words, you can't tell them apart no matter how hard you try. If you want to read a book or check out a movie where the relationship between a straight man and a gay man is close to perfect, Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil does an excellent job.

I don't want anyone to get the wrong impression here. I'm not dissing effeminate gay men or the women who love them. Personally, I love women...I appreciate their energy most of all. And I have had, and still have, many gay male friends who love feathers, rhinestones, and glitter. I love them, too. But the lgbt community isn't what it appears to be on the surface. I think this is changing as time passes and more people start to feel comfortable with themselves and their sexuality. If I'd been born thirty years earlier, I wouldn't be writing gay fiction openly, I wouldn't be writing this blog post right now. I would most likely have been in the closet, sneaking around on the down low...like so many gay men are still doing today.

But the fact remains, gay men are still men. And no matter how anyone tries to twist it around, it's always going to be this way.





10 comments:

Michele Jensen said...

Well said, Ryan. Nothing is more frustrating to me as an editor than to receive a lgbt story in which the characters are constructed using stereotypes. It's insulting to my intelligence and sometimes quite offensive.

Emma Lai said...

It's always interesting to me how people take one characteristic and twist it for their own needs rather than try and understand a person.

For example, when I was an engineer (the only female in my group), I heard, 'You're just like one of the guys,' more times than I can count. Yeah...no. I might not be overly emotional, and I might be able to take an insult without breaking down into tears, but that doesn't mean I'm like a guy. I know many times it was a justification for the guys to themselves so they'd feel comfortable around me, but sheesh...

ryan field said...

Thanks for commenting...I learn more from comments sometimes than other posts I read online!!

Kei-chan said...

I'm so with you on this. If I wanted to read a story with a female character in it I would read het fiction. I don't want to read about a female character masquerading as a man.

My ultimate pet peeve? The shy blushing virgin who is hanging back. Come on! When was the last time you heard of a guy who wasn't in a rush to get rid of his virginity. He might be unsure of some of the mechanics of the whole thing, but he sure as hell was looking forward to the experience.

Keep the stories and blog coming, Ryan!
Kei

Anonymous said...

Well, I tend to see sexual orientation as more like a fan in the open position. With a few on the ends, the extremes, and most falling somewhere between. Some closer to the extremes than others, some squarely in the middle.
In Hollywood, they are selling fiction. Although they occasionally 'get it right', for the most part it is commercial fluff, and should NEVER be used as part of any serious standard! So much harm has been done to delicate self-esteems by the incessant focus on appearance. Hollywood doesn't only entertain, it educates as well. It teaches people what is considered important...the perfect face, the perfect body...*SIGH!!!* And it also gives us equally false ideas of what we should BE.
Too much fakery, too much "posing". What we need is not necessarily more descriptions of gay men as MEN, or as any other particular thing, but as "regular folk" just like the rest of us, with as much diversity amongst their own as we straights have. Some are liberal, some conservative, some very emotional, some stoic, some like feathers, rhinestones and glitter, and others prefer plaid shirts and worn jeans. But all are legitimate expressions...

ryan field said...

Well said, Anon!!

Sue Brown said...

I'm caught between a rock and a hard place here. On the one hand, as one of my friends says, "I'm gay, not dumb. I can work out the rules of football." This is in response to his brother in law who feels the need to explain the rules every time he sees him.

On the other hand, I hate (and won't) use the effeminate, hand-flapping gay stereotype but if I make them the same as all the straight blokes I'm accused of knowing nothing about gay men and their lifestyle.

ryan field said...

I think Anon @6:00 said it best. There are effeminate gay men and there's nothing wrong with that. One of my best friends, and older guy, was Miss Fire Island and I miss him to this day. But the gay community is very diverse, and so many are still closeted.

Anonymous said...

I really love the idea of exploring and developing non-traditional versions of characters that tend to get the 'stereotype treatment'. I suppose established media are hesitant to go outside the accepted pattern, but I'd like to see say, TV shows willing to show a gay man with NO taste who actually can't STAND Lady Gaga, and who doesn't understand WHY his boyfriend gets upset when he tries to go out in plaid shorts, a Hawaiian shirt, and sandals with black kneesocks...Or a gay man with surprisingly non-liberal views on some hot-button issue...
(cyra)

ryan field said...

Cyra...I touched on this with my book The Way We Almost Were. There's a reader review on amazon that explains the political aspects.

I agree. Believe me, I know an equal amount of gay men who are extremely conservative with politics. They all belong to the Gay Log Cabin Club.