Tuesday, February 17, 2009

Follow up on Lasting Love Submissions...

After the post about all the great submissions for the Lasting Love anthology, I had to follow up with this short post. As I said, all the submissions were good, and I have a feeling that the one I didn't actually get a chance to read was good, too.

I'll explain. Last Friday afternoon I received a last minute e-mail from a writer who wanted to submit for the anthology, but didn't see the call for submission until that week. The deadline was Saturday, and the writer wanted to know if they could submit early the following week. They couldn't submit on Saturday because of religious reasons, and apologized a thousand times. So I replied and said they could submit on Monday or Tuesday. I wasn't sure if I'd be working on Sunday (I did anyway) so there would still be time early in the week to read the short story. I don't know how other editors feel, but when someone contacts me at the last minute with a well written e-mail and a good voice, I'm curious and I want to know more about them.

As it turned out, this writer didn't get a chance to submit anything because of the time factor. And I understood that; I've been there myself. The writer e-mailed me after reading the Lasting Love post I wrote, and explained this in another well written, professional e-mail.

So if this writer is reading this post, I'm hoping they continue to follow the ravenous romance calls for submissions, because now I'm really curious.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

I just read American Star on Monday and loved it. I can't wait for the second season!

Anonymous said...

I'm glad the writer's quality caught your eye. I hope you get to read work by the person and it's as wonderful as the letter seems to suggest.

But I'm much more of a hardliner than you are, as both a writer and an editor.

In my mind, a deadline's a deadline. I don't work with soft deadlines, I work with hard deadlines. They exist to make things flow smoothly in the overall process, and make the most of everyone's time. If I find out about a deadline just before it's due, and I want to submit, I do whatever it takes to get the submission in (if it means working all night, that's what I do), or else I pass and see when the next opportunity with that particular place comes up. I don't expect special treatment -- the editor's time is too valuable. I especially don't expect special treatment if the editor is someone with whom I haven't worked previously and has no reason to extend him or herself for me. Honestly, I think it's disrespectful to even ask.

And, since you were kind enough to agree to an extension, it was up to the writer to do whatever it took to get the submission in and prove the writer's reliability. If you're going to talk the talk, walk the walk. And when someone goes out of his/her way to accommodate your request, you step up and deliver. Period.

A strong portion of being a working, paid, regularly published writer is the ability to deliver as promised and work on deadline. That's just as important in fiction as it is in non-fiction.

Of course, I'm jaded by years of empty promises by writers who have no follow-through. I'm glad you're not at that point, and I hope you never get there!